by 
Located at 9432 Bay City Forestville Rd, Fairgrove, MI 48733, Bay Shore Bar & Grill serves up hearty meals and a welcoming atmosphere just east of the Quanicassee River. Known for its laid-back roadhouse vibe, this hidden gem has earned a reputation as a go-to stop for travelers, locals, and anyone craving fresh, flavorful fare. From crispy fried fish to gut-busting nachos, Bay Shore is more than a bar and grill—it’s a Michigan must-visit for food and good times.
A Taste of Bay Shore’s Offerings
Bay Shore Bar & Grill has crafted a niche for itself with some stellar specialties:
- Fresh Fish Fry Fridays: Diners rave about the Friday fish fry, featuring locally sourced yellow belly lake perch. Cod and walleye options are also available, often leaving guests impressed with crispy perfection and generous portions.
- Signature Burgers & Sandwiches: Forget frozen patties—Bay Shore’s fresh ground chuck burgers consistently get nods for their juicy flavor and satisfying bite. Patrons also praise the steak and perch sandwiches.
- Family-Sized Nachos: When they say big, they mean it—Bay Shore’s nacho supreme feeds up to six people, making it a group favorite.
What Makes It Special?
Bay Shore Bar & Grill stands out not only for its menu but also for its atmosphere and service:
- Roadhouse Atmosphere: Guests frequently highlight the nostalgic, fun decor, including Harley memorabilia and themed bathroom décor—yes, even the restrooms have character!
- Attentive Staff: Reviews reflect a friendly and engaged waitstaff who often go above and beyond to accommodate customer needs. Special shout-outs to waitresses like Darcy, who make the experience memorable with exceptional service.
Highlights & Hiccups: Real Reviews Tell the Story
The Highlights
- Great Food & Fun Vibes: Many patrons love the unique vibe of Bay Shore, noting it as a great pit stop for road trips, camping breaks, and casual hangouts.
- “Friday Perch dinner was absolutely out of this world!” – Steve R.
- “The service was awesome, very friendly and engaging… But even more impressive, the food was great.” – Art Troupe
- Welcoming to Everyone—Even Pets: The dog-friendly patio earns major points for thoughtful touches, such as water bowls and treats for furry companions.
- Memorable Meals: Steak sandwiches, Philly wraps, and perfectly cooked cod all make strong impressions on diners, with many expressing intentions to return.
The Hiccups
- Occasional Service Delays: A few guests noted slow service during peak times, possibly due to Bay Shore’s smaller kitchen setup.
- “Food was great once it arrived… but the food seemed to take a long time to prepare.” – Roland Aumock
- Hit or Miss Consistency: While many visitors rave about their experiences, some encountered burnt burgers or underwhelming dishes. Management’s responsive replies to such reviews show their commitment to improvement.
Our Verdict: Is Bay Shore Worth the Stop?
In short—yes! Bay Shore Bar & Grill delivers on hearty, flavorful food in a fun, welcoming space that keeps guests coming back. Whether you’re on a road trip or just looking for a satisfying meal with a side of nostalgia, it’s well worth the visit. Just be prepared to wait a bit during busy hours, and you’ll leave with a full stomach and a smile.
Explore Great Food and Food Destinations
Discover unique eateries across Michigan and beyond at Explore Great Food and Food Destinations. Savor traditional tastes and hidden gems.
Top Food and Drink in Michigan
Michigan’s food scene offers Great Lakes flavors and farm-to-table favorites. Check out more on Top Food and Drink In Michigan.
Thumbwind’s Great Food Feature Stories
Explore the best of Michigan’s culinary landscape, from local recipes to food trucks, at Thumbwind’s Great Food Feature Stories.
Your Turn – Was this Review a Hit?, or a Miss? – We Want To Hear From You
Please offer an insightful and thoughtful comment. Idiotic, profane, or threatening comments are eliminated without remorse. Consider sharing this story. Follow us to have other feature stories appear in your email from ThumbWind Publications.
Discover more from Thumbwind
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
