by 
Do a bit of research on Port Austin, and you can’t help but run into this picture of a large building; the Point of Pines Hotel. Postcards indicate it was active from 1898 until 1935. But little else is recorded. I saw that an original hotel registry was for sale on eBay. Someone found the registry at a flea market in Chicago. Today, that original registry from the hotel can be seen at the Port Austin History Center.
Some prominent people stayed at the hotel, including Hazen S. Pingree. Pingree stayed at the hotel as the 24th governor of the State of Michigan from 1897 – 1901. He was also a four-term Republican mayor of Detroit.
Then I found this ad with the name “M.M. Buttars, Proprietor.” The Buttars was a prominent pioneer family in Port Austin and Port Crescent. It turns out that M. M. was Mary Maxwell Buttars. Not only did she own and run the resort, but she also sold cloth and picture frames.
The ownership looks to have passed to James Cartwright in December 1911. The “Journal for Retail Merchants” noted that Cartwright was retiring from his retail business to run the Point of Pines with his son.
In 1931 the hotel looked to have been owned by William Dormey, a prominent area businessman who operated the Dormey’s Blue Water Inn in Caseville starting in 1932. His Whitefish and Chicken dinner combination looks famous in the area.
The search is on to find more about this exciting piece of Port Austin history. We bet there are great stories and photos about this resort buried in a file cabinet about the Point of Pines Hotel.
*Cover Image Courtesy of the Burton Historical Collection, Detroit Public Library
History of Michigan For Kids on Amazon
Related Reading to the Point of Pines Hotel
The Bay Port Hotel – The Bay Port Hotel was a resort. Using rail as transport, guests could get to the calm waters of Wild Fowl Bay in a 1/2 a day, yet still have all the amenities of a big city hotel. The days of frontier resorts would soon end in the early 1900s as lumbering ended in Michigan.
Indian Villages and Sites in Huron County, Michigan – Upon its ninety miles of shoreline were numerous Indian villages and camps. These were found due to the debris left by the dwellers. The Indians in Huron County, Michigan, had a village site every few miles along the shore of Saginaw Bay.
Caseville Harbor History Compared to Fishtown – It’s only been in the last 60 years that Caseville was known as a sport fishing and pleasure boat vacation spot. Before the marinas and boat slip, it was just docked along the Pigeon River. Buildings from the iron foundry, sawmill, and salt block stood as an industrial powerhouse from Caseville’s Days.
The Corner Drug & Jewelry Store Harbor Beach, Michigan – This iconic Harbor Beach store continues today as a unique retailer with a wide range of products. The Corner Store in Harbor Beach offers vinyl records, CDs, posters, memorabilia, magazines, and entertainment collectibles. It also has a selection of vintage, collectible books focused on Michigan and the Thumb region.
Discover more from Thumbwind
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
The Port Austin History Center has the original hotel registry on display. A Society member purchased it on eBay and donated it. Guest signatures date back to 1896.
That is cool. I will update the post with that information.
Trying to find information on a place off of 23 In Grindstone City called The Ranch or Ed’s Ranch. Had music and hotel rooms. My parents owned it in the 1950’s but both are gone now.
Interesting…let us check to see if the older locals know anything