By 1900 most place names in the Thumb had reached a high degree of stability and permanence. The most notable change in Huron county place-name change occurred in 1898 when the Harbor of Refuge was completed in 1882, Sand Beach was changed to Harbor Beach. At this same time, Bad Axe Mi. almost lost a unique and treasured name.
The Name of Bad Axe Michigan Almost Changed
Unsuccessful efforts to change the name of Bad Axe were made before 1900 and again in 1907 and again in 1909. A score of new names was suggested, including Hubbard, Axworthy, Huronia, Huron, and Huron City. In 1907 the locally prominent orator William Lyon Phelps, a well-known Yale University professor, supported the proposal to change the name.
The Detroit Free Press defended the name, saying in an editorial, “Publicity is being given to a movement at Bad Axe to change the town’s name. Euphony is desirable … in geographical nomenclature, but characteristic, distinctive qualities are also desirable. With our Wayne’s and our Newport’s and Marshalls … we can’t spare our Bad Axe just yet from the Michigan map … If an effort to substitute something commonplace and hackneyed and stale for Bad Axe should be successful, who knows, but some might want to change the name of Kalamazoo or Ypsilanti.”*
Michigan Legislature Changes the Name, Sorta
In 1909 the state legislature changed the name of Bad Axe to Huron subject to a referendum of the city’s voters. No election to ratify the name change was ever held because the Common Council of the city took the position that it was definitely known how the vote would result. This being true, an election costing about one hundred dollars would be a needless expense. As far as the writer knows, the only place that changed its name after 1900 was Poverty Nook, which was renamed Hemans in 1914 for the Michigan historian Lawton T. Hemans.
How did Bad Axe Mi., the only town in the world with this name, get its appellation? Local lore states that during the lumbering era George Martin left a ruined ax at the site of a well know Indian encampment. In the spring of 1861, George Willis Pack and Rudolph Papst were laying out a road from Bay City to Sand Beach. At a place where a road ran north and south, they found a broken, rusty ax embedded in a tree. They called the intersection Bad Axe Corners and indicated so on survey documents. In 1885 the village was incorporated and the name shortened to Bad Axe. In 1905 the city of Bad Axe was formed.
*Detroit, Free Press, May 25, 1907
Excerpt from A HISTORY OF MICHIGAN’S THUMB by Gerard Schultz 1964. P 70
Related Bad Axe Mi and Michigan’s Upper Thumb Reading
- Over 100 years ago, illustrations started to appear in the newspapers of Michigan’s Upper Thumb. The following was on the front page of the Harbor Beach Times on January 5th, 1917. Was food scarce? Coal was also in short supply, causing layoffs of fisherman and the sugar beet processing plant in Mt. Clemens. It’s an interesting observation of Harbor Beach’s history.100 Years Ago – Tough Times in Harbor Beach
- One of the roadside treats for me when I come up the Thumb on Fridays after work is to go through the tiny village of Kilmanagh. The iconic Kilmanagh general store and vintage gas pump are always worth a slow roll to see what has changed. Kilmanagh General Store – Saving A Great Thumb Icon –
- Amazingly you can now see how Michigan’s Upper Thumb region has changed in the past 30 years. Google’s Earth Engine gives a global time-lapse view built from annual composites of Landsat satellite images. Including Bad Axe Mi. Watch the growth of Michigan’s Thumb across Huron County’s landscape beginning as early as 1984. See 30 Years of Amazing Changes in Michigan’s Thumb
- There is nothing like the familiar foods of home. If you have spent any time in Michigan, you will find many posts for our love of UP Pasties, Faygo RedPop, BetterMade potato chips, and Vernor’s ginger ale. That is only the beginning. Michigan has unique and tasty comfort food dishes originating from Michigan’s Upper Peninsula to the Ohio and Indiana border. These Hometown Foods Scream That You’re from Michigan
- In 1963 Caseville was trying to emerge as a tourist destination. One place to rest and relax was the tiny Palmer Motel across from the county park.